OVERVIEW

HISTORY

ACTORS

MAPS

DIMENSIONS:

ecosystem
wildlife
economic
policy
recreation/aesthetic
social

STUDY TEAM

REFERENCES

Overview

Since its creation in 1872, Yellowstone National Park has been a place set-aside for the conservation of nature and a place for citizens to experience wilderness.  One famous aspect of this wilderness is theYellowstone cutthroat trout (Oncorhynchus clarki bouvieri) which is easily viewed and caught by anglers.  In 1868, even before the creation of the park, a journalist wrote of the YellowstoneLake "It is filled with fish half as large as a man, some which have a mouth and horns and skin like a catfish and legs like a lizard."  Although this man may have gone a little overboard, this statement embodies the enthusiasm with which some anglers boast of their experiences fishing in the park.

In the past, just this kind of enthusiasm has led to the decline of the trout fishery caused by over harvest and poor management.  With newer regulations such as catch-and-release policies and catch limits beginning in the 1960s the Yellowstone trout populations have since rebounded.  However, a new problem exists in the form of an introduced species to the lake.  Lake trout (Salvelinus namaycush) were discovered in 1994 and assumed to be introduced years before. The lake trout pose a threat not only to the native cutthroat but also to the entire ecosystem. The cutthroat are threatened by the lake trout because they compete for the same resources when they are young and are also eaten by the larger lake trout. A large lake trout can eat up to 3,000 cutthroat in its lifetime. Furthermore, cutthroat are a major source of food for many terrestrial animals. Since the lake trout live and breed in deeper waters than the cutthroat, land animals cannot prey on them. The land animals are also threatened due to the massive consumption of cutthroat trout by lake trout. Scientists estimate that without control of the lake trout population the cutthroat trout population will drop by 10%-20%.


“It is filled with fish half as large as a man, some which
have a mouth and horns and skin like a catfish and legs
like a lizard.”

 

Despite the challenges faced by the Yellowstone cutthroat, countless numbers of anglers come to the park every year in order to have the ultimate wilderness experience. The park is surrounded by fly fishing outfitters and companies that provide fishing trips and tours in the park. Both the local economy and the park economy rely heavily on the fishing business. The extreme popularity of fishing in the park has raised some controversial issues. Is the catch and release policy really a better alternative for the fish? Should the waters of the park be restored to what they were before they were stocked with fish?

Yellowstone National Park has attracted families for generations. Coming to one of the wildest parks in America is sometimes the only chance that people have to view actual wildlife and to experience what America used to be. For these reasons more and more visitors are coming to the park not to catch the fish but to watch them. Fishing Bridge and Lehardy Rapids, now closed to fishing, have become fish viewing hot spots. Almost 300,000 visitors stopped in these areas simply to view the cutthroat in their natural habitat.

The issues surrounding fish are complex and deep-rooted in society. Even the 19th Century composer Franz Schubert wrote a song about trout fishing. Despite the complexities, the problems facing the cutthroat fisheries in Yellowstone cannot be ignored. The over harvest and poor management of the cutthroat and the threat of the lake trout are serious problems that if not dealt with can cause the extinction of one of the largest populations of cutthroat trout in the world.